[Reader-users] Let's get some discussion going

[tribble]

Hi James -- I do hope the A/B units will continue to be supported as I and 
many others have invested a lot of money in it -- but as for whether it is a 
good idea to go mobile, I think it is great as a pocket sized unit would be 
so much easier to carry around, and the hardware is out there that can 
support such a thing -- most all phones now have cameras and processors, so 
putting the software on it seems like a natural evolution. I am reminded 
though of the use CodeFactory made of the phone cameras to write software to 
identifier color and lighting for blind users.  The software only costed 
something like $30 but I thought it was a really creative use of the camera, 
which many blind phone customers thought they would never need to use. 
however, I bought the color recognizer and frankly it didn't work worth a 
hoot -- I mean, you had to recalibrate it every time your surroundings 
changed or it would give ridiculous results, and if a blind person needs to 
depend on knowing when lighting changes in order to use the recognizer, it 
turned out to be a loser.  But I must say it was a nice try. In the end I 
did go and buy the color test from APH for their ridiculously high price, 
which differs in that it has its own light source and doesn't depend on --  
and in fact can't work when there is -- ambient light.  They have a cheaper 
model for a third the price, but I opted for the color test as I tried the 
other one at convention on some clothes I brought along and it didn't work. 
I have been happy with the color test.

But back to the reader, if there are similar gotchas for the knfb stuff 
being put on a mobile phone, then I would be leary of sinking money into it. 
Otherwise, if it indeed would work as well as the original units, I might 
scrape into my budget yet again and consider getting one -- maybe after it 
has been out a while.  (I'm still reeling from an unexpected veterinarian 
bill for my little dog who got away and tangled with a fast moving car...)
Is there a projected price tag on the mobile reader?
Cheers!
--le



----- Original Message ----- 
From: "James Jolley" <james.jolley at homecall.co.uk>
To: "Kurzweil National Federation of the Blind Reader user list" 
<reader-users at nfbnet.org>
Sent: Saturday, January 26, 2008 6:28 AM
Subject: [Reader-users] Let's get some discussion going


Hi folks,

I got to thinking about this after the news regarding the mobile
product line. What do people think to perhaps buying it as a secondary
machine if they could afford it? For me, thinking on what Jim said,
the A and B units surely would continue to have updates as the PDA in
both of them is fast for what we're doing. After all, it doesn't take
600 MHZ or so of processing to do OCR, indeed I remember doing it on
open book years ago with a 486 DX33. In honesty, do people think that
the unit is small enough as it is? Getting these things onto mobiles
is all well and good but as you know, aiming and holding a mobile
phone straight is difficult for some. My only worry about all this
miniaturization is that we may forget that these are reading machines
first and foremost.

What do people think?

Best

-James-
_______________________________________________
Reader-users mailing list
Reader-users at nfbnet.org
http://www.nfbnet.org/mailman/listinfo/reader-users